Calculus Of One Real Variable
By Pheng Kim Ving
Chapter 6: The Trigonometric Functions And Their Inverses
Group 6.3: Transcendency
Section 6.3.1: Transcendental Functions

 

6.3.1
Transcendental Functions

 

 

Return To Contents
Go To Problems & Solutions

 

1. Rational And Irrational Numbers

 

 

Of course a rational number m/n satisfies the equation:

 

nx – m = 0,

 

 

 

can be converted to a polynomial equation with integer coefficients by multiplying both sides by the least common multiple of
the denominators bi's and simplify to get the equivalent (having same solution(s)) equation:

 

cnxn + cn–1xn–1 + cn–2xn–2 + ... + c1x + c0  = 0,

 

where the ci's are integers. So there's no loss of generality that encompasses the rational coefficients to consider equations
with integer coefficients instead of equations with rational coefficients.

 

Definition 1.1 – Rational And Irrational Numbers

 

 

 

Return To Top Of Page     Go To Problems & Solutions

 

2. Algebraic And Transcendental Numbers

 

 

Definition 2.1 – Algebraic And Transcendental Numbers

 

 

 

Remarks 2.1

 

 

Return To Top Of Page     Go To Problems & Solutions

 

3. Algebraic And Transcendental Functions

 

The function:

 

 

 

is constructed by using an operation that doesn't apply directly or explicitly to polynomials in x finitely many times. It can be
shown that:

 

 

 

which involves the additions of infinitely  many terms containing increasing odd powers of x with alternating signs. It's
demonstrated in Section 15.3 Part 3. Note that sin x of course depends on x, that's why it's a function of x, but not directly in a
finite manner, instead in an infinite manner. An approximate value of sin x can be calculated by using the sum of the first k
terms in Eq. [3.3], where k is a positive integer. The larger the integer k, the better the approximation.

 

A function f (x) is said to be identically 0 if it's always 0, ie, if f (x) = 0 for all x in dom( f ). Thus a polynomial p(x) is
identically 0 if all of its coefficients are 0. We see that a function f (x) isn't identically 0 if there's at least some x where f (x)
isn't 0. Thus a polynomial p(x) isn't identically 0 if at least one of its coefficients isn't 0.

 

An algebraic function of x is one that can be constructed by using finitely  many algebraic operations of addition, subtraction,
multiplication, division, or raising to constant powers applied to polynomials in x (the nth root of an expression is that
expression raised to the constant power of 1/n, so extraction of roots is included in raising to constant powers). It's a
polynomial in x or a finite combination of algebraic operations applied to polynomials in x. Now, as suggested by the fact that
function [3.1] satisfies Eq. [3.2], a function f (x) can be constructed by using finitely many algebraic operations iff it satisfies a
polynomial equation in function y with polynomial coefficients and non-identically 0 leading coefficient. The term "algebraic"
means finitely many normal algebraic operations, in the sense that the values of the function may be calculated algebraically in
a finite manner for all the values of the variable.

 

A function f (x) is said to be a transcendental function  if it's not algebraic, ie, if it can't be constructed by using finitely  many
algebraic operations of addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, or raising to constant powers applied to polynomials in x,
ie, if it's a function that doesn't satisfy any polynomial equation in function y with polynomial coefficients and non-identically 0
leading coefficient. The term "transcendental" doesn't imply anything deep or mysterious. It simply means transcending the
normal algebraic operations, in the sense that the values of the function may not be calculated algebraically in a finite manner
for some or all of the values of the variable.

 

Definition 3.1 – Algebraic And Transcendental Functions

 

 

 

Remarks 3.1

 

 

2. Remark that Eq. [3.4] is similar to Eq. [1.1]: the variable x is replaced by the function y and the constants ai's are replaced
    by the polynomials pi(x)'s. As for the function sin x, now we see it's transcendental.

 

3. Some other examples of algebraic functions:

 

 

4. The right-hand side of Eq. [3.3] is the infinite expansion of the transcendental function sin x. Many algebraic functions also
    each have an infinite expansion. So if a function has an infinite expansion, that doesn't mean that it has to be
    transcendental.

 

Analogy

 

The definition of algebraic numbers is analogous to that of algebraic functions: algebraic numbers are those that satisfy
polynomial equations in variable x with integer coefficients, algebraic functions are those that satisfy polynomial equations in
function y with polynomial coefficients.

 

The definition of transcendental numbers is analogous to that of transcendental functions: transcendental numbers are those
that aren't algebraic numbers, transcendental functions are those that aren't algebraic functions.

 

A rational number is a number that is or can be written as a ratio m/n, where m and n are integers and n > 0. Recall that a
rational function is a function that is or can be written as a ratio p(x)/q(x), where p(x) and q(x) are polynomials and q(x) isn't
identically 0.

 

The status of the polynomials in the set of all functions is analogous to that of the integers in the set of all numbers.

 

Example 3.1

 

Prove that the function f (x) = |x| is algebraic.

 

Solution
Let y = |x|. Then:


y2 = |x|2 = x2,
y2 – x2 = 0.
 

The function f (x) = |x| satisfies the algebraic equation y2 – x2 = 0, and so is algebraic.

EOS

 

Theorem 3.1 – Transcendency Of Non-0 Constant Multiples Of Transcendental Functions

 

For any non-0 constant c, a function f (x) is transcendental iff c f (x)  is transcendental.

 

 

Note

Of course 0 f (x) = 0 = 0x for all x in dom( f ), so 0f (x) is an algebraic function, whether f (x) is algebraic or transcendental.

 

Proof

EOP

 

Return To Top Of Page

 

Problems & Solutions

 

 

Solution

 

Let:

 

 

Return To Top Of Page

 

Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: bd10307_

 

2. State whether the following functions are algebraic or transcendental.

 

 

 

Solution

 

a. Algebraic.
b. Transcendental.
c. Algebraic.

 

Return To Top Of Page

 

Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: bd10307_

 

3. Prove that the function:

 

 

    is algebraic.

 

Solution

 

Let:

 

 

The function f (x) satisfies the last algebraic equation with polynomial coefficients, and so is algebraic.

 

Return To Top Of Page

 

Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: bd10307_

 

4. Consider the function f (x) = sgn x, where “sgn” stands for the Latin word “signum” and is pronounced “sik-nem”. The Latin
    word “signum” means “sign”. The function is defined as follows:

 

 

    Prove that it‘s algebraic by finding an algebraic equation that it satisfies.

 

Solution

 

Let y = sgn x.

 

If x > 0 then y = 1, so y3 = 1 = y, thus y3 – y = 0,
if x = 0 then y = 0, so y3 = 0 = y, thus y3 – y = 0,
if x < 0 then y = –1, so y3 = –1 = y, thus y3 – y = 0.

 

Consequently the function f (x) = sgn x satisfies the algebraic equation y3 – y = 0, and so is algebraic.

 

Return To Top Of Page

 

Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: bd10307_

 

5. Prove that if a function f (x) is transcendental, then 1 + f (x)  is transcendental.

 

Solution

 

 

 

 

 

 

Substitute these expansions into Eq. [1]. Factor all the like powers of f (x). Then we get an equation of the form:

 

qn(x) f n(x) + qn–1(x) f n–1(x) + q–2(x) f n–2(x) + … + q1(x) f (x) + q0(x) = 0,

 

where the qk(x)'s are polynomials and qn(x) = pn(x) for all x and thus qn(x) is non-identically 0, that's satisfied by all x in
dom( f ). This shows that f (x) is algebraic, a contradiction. Consequently, 1 + f (x) must be transcendental.

 

Return To Top Of Page     Return To Contents